Skip to main content

Captchas

When are Captchas required?​

Captchas are required at two places in the Bitwarden codebase:

  • Registration, via the [CapchaProtected] attribute
  • Login, via the ResourceOwnerPasswordValidator

Each of these cases have slightly different validation for whether a captcha is required.

Registration: [CaptchaProtected] anonymous endpoint​

The only endpoint protected with the [CaptchaProtected] attribute is the /register endpoint on the Identity service. This endpoint is anonymous, so no authentication middleware can perform the captcha checks.

For these requests, the server requires a captcha if either of the following are true:

  • The CloudFlare x-Cf-Is-Bot header is present on the request, or
  • The ForceCaptchaRequired setting is enabled

Login: Token requests authenticated with Resource Owner Password authentication​

Requests against /identity/connect/token in the Identity service are validated with the ResourceOwnerPasswordValidator. In this validator, we perform different checks to see if a captcha is required, since the endpoint is authenticated and we know the user from the request (assuming they are authenticated successfully).

Known Devices

No captchas are ever required for known devices. This check is performed before any of the rules below are applied.

For these requests, the server requires a captcha if any of the following are true:

  • The CloudFlare x-Cf-Is-Bot header is present on the request
  • The ForceCaptchaRequired setting is enabled
  • The failed login count is greater than the MaximumFailedLoginAttempts setting
  • The request is for a cloud-hosted user whose email is not verified and has not registered within the last 24 hours

The CLI performs the same captcha checks on the bw login command, but instead of prompting for a captcha it accepts the API client secret. The server handles this API client secret as a “captcha response” in the logic below.

How do Captchas work in our code?​

At a high level, the server initiates and validates captcha requirements, and the client handles that requirement by displaying the captcha and gathering the response to validate server-side.

In more detail, the process is as follows:

  1. The server receives a request requiring a captcha using the rules defined above.
  2. The server then responds with a response containing our HCaptcha_SiteKey, which the client interprets as “this request requires a captcha”.
  3. The front-end displays the captcha <div> based on this response, using the showCaptcha() method on the CaptchaProtectedComponent.
  4. The CaptchaProtectedComponent takes as input a CaptchaIFrame component, which contains the actual captcha UI.
  5. CaptchaProtectedComponent handles the successCallback of the CaptchaIFrame by setting the captchaToken property to the value from the captcha response.
  6. The user can then initiate the action again (logging in, registering, etc.). The captchaToken will be sent with the request as another element in the body.
  7. The server validates the request in the HCaptchaValidationService by POSTing a message to https://hcaptcha.com/siteverify containing the token and our site key.

What is a Captcha Bypass Token?​

There are scenarios where there are multiple requests from the same user to one of the captcha-protected endpoints. We want to “bypass” the captcha requirement on subsequent requests based on the fact that they have already filled out the captcha before, even if those subsequent requests would have required a captcha by the definition of the rules above.

We do this with a captcha bypass token. This is a token created on the server for the first request when the captcha is verified, containing:

  • User ID
  • User email
  • Expiration date (5 minutes from generation)

Because the captcha bypass token is generated with the user’s information, it is only checked on the Login captcha validation. It doesn’t make sense to check in the Register captcha validation, because a registering user would not have a valid User ID.

The token is protected using our data protection key on the server and sent back in the CaptchaBypassToken element with the format BWCaptchaBypass_{tokenContents}.

The client can then use that captchaResponse in subsequent requests for the next 5 minutes from that same user in order to bypass the captcha requirements. The server-side code treats this bypass token the same way as it treats a captchaResponse gathered from the display of the captcha UI.

Captcha bypass tokens are not needed in most user flows, because the user is logging in from a known device. Logging in from a known device bypasses all captcha requirements, so a token is not required.